LectitōOpen the reader

Lectitō › Seneca › On Mercy (De Clementia) › De Clementia 12

Seneca · De Clementia

De Clementia 12

Kings and tyrants contrasted

English onlyRead it word by word

Clem. 1.12.1" Quid ergō ?'What follows, then? Clem. 1.12.1Nōn rēgēs quoque occīdere solent ?Are kings too not in the habit of killing? Clem. 1.12.1" Sed quotiēns id fierī pūblica ūtilitās persuādet;' Yes, but whenever the public good persuades them that it should be done; Clem. 1.12.1tyrannīs saevitia cordī est.to tyrants savagery is dear. Clem. 1.12.1Tyrannus autem ā rēge factīs distat, nōn nōmine ;But a tyrant differs from a king in deeds, not in name; Clem. 1.12.1nam et Dionȳsius maior iūre meritōque praeferrī multīs rēgibus potest, et L. Sullam tyrannum appellārī quid prohibet, cui occīdendī fīnem fēcit inopia hostium ?for Dionysius the elder may rightly and deservedly be preferred to many kings, and what prevents Lucius Sulla from being called a tyrant, whose killing was ended only by a lack of enemies? Clem. 1.12.2Dēscenderit licet ē dictātūrā suā et sē togae reddiderit, quis tamen umquam tyrannus tam avidē hūmānum sanguinem bibit quam ille, quī septem mīlia cīvium Rōmānōrum contrucīdārī iussit et, cum in vīcīnō ad aedem Bellōnae sedēns exaudīsset conclāmātiōnem tot mīlium sub gladiō gementium, exterritō senātū : " Hoc agāmus," inquit, " patrēs cōnscrīptī;Granted that he stepped down from his dictatorship and returned to the toga, yet what tyrant ever drank human blood so greedily as he, who ordered seven thousand Roman citizens to be butchered, and who, sitting nearby at the temple of Bellona and hearing the outcry of so many thousands groaning under the sword, said to the terrified senate: 'Let us attend to business, conscript fathers; Clem. 1.12.2sēditiōsī pauculī meō iussū occīduntur " ?a handful of rebels are being put to death on my orders'?

Clem. 1.12.3Hoc nōn est mentītus ;In this he did not lie; Clem. 1.12.3paucī Sullae vidēbantur.they seemed few to Sulla. Clem. 1.12.3Sed mox dē Sullā, cum quaerēmus, quōmodo hostibus īrāscendum sit, utique sī in hostīle nōmen cīvēs et ex eōdem corpore abruptī trānsierint ;But of Sulla presently, when we ask how one should be angry with enemies, especially if citizens, torn away from the same body, have passed over to the name of enemy; Clem. 1.12.3interim, hoc quod dīcēbam, clēmentia efficit, ut magnum inter rēgem tyrannumque discrīmen sit, uterque licet nōn minus armīs vallētur ;meanwhile, as I was saying, clemency brings it about that there is a great difference between a king and a tyrant, though both alike are fenced about with arms; Clem. 1.12.3sed alter arma habet, quibus in mūnīmentum pācis ūtitur, alter, ut magnō timōre magna odia compescat, nec illās ipsās manūs, quibus sē commīsit, sēcūrus adspicit.but the one has arms which he uses to fortify peace, the other in order to suppress great hatreds by great fear, and not even the very hands to which he has entrusted himself does he look upon without anxiety.

Clem. 1.12.4Contrāriīs in contrāria agitur ;He is driven by contrary forces into contrary courses; Clem. 1.12.4nam cum invīsus sit, quia timētur, timērī vult, quia invīsus est, et illō exsecrābilī versū, quī multōs praecipitēs dedit, ūtitur : "Ōderint, dum metuant," ignārus, quanta rabiēs oriātur, ubi suprā modum odia crēvērunt.for since he is hated because he is feared, he wants to be feared because he is hated, and he takes up that accursed line which has sent many headlong, 'Let them hate, so long as they fear', not knowing what madness arises when hatreds have grown beyond measure. Clem. 1.12.4Temperātus enim timor cohibet animōs, adsiduus vērō et ācer et extrēma admovēns in audāciam iacentēs excitat et omnia experīrī suādet.For a moderate fear restrains minds, but one that is constant and sharp and threatens the utmost rouses even the prostrate to boldness and urges them to try everything. Clem. 1.12.5Sīc ferās līnea et pinnae clūsās contineant ;So a cord hung with feathers may keep wild beasts penned in; Clem. 1.12.5eāsdem ā tergō eques tēlīs incessat, temptābunt fugam per ipsa, quae fūgerant, prōculcābuntque formīdinem.let a horseman attack the same beasts with spears from behind, and they will try to flee through the very things they had fled from, and will trample their terror underfoot.

Clem. 1.12.5Ācerrima- virtūs est quam, ultima necessitās extundit extundit.The fiercest courage is that which utmost necessity hammers out. Clem. 1.12.5Relinquat oportet sēcūrī aliquid metūs multōque plūs speī quam perīculōrum ostentet ;Fear must leave something secure, and show far more hope than danger; Clem. 1.12.5aliōquī, ubi quiēscentī paria metuuntur, incurrere in perīcula iuvat et aliēnā animā abūtī.otherwise, when a man who keeps quiet has as much to fear, he is glad to rush into dangers and to spend his life as if it were another's.

Read the Latin itself: tap any word for its meaning and grammar, save words to review, and keep your place.

Read in Lectitō

Grammar in this passage: indirect statement ×1, gerunds and gerundives ×2, ablative absolute ×1

Latin vocabulary for this passage (197 words)
quis, quid, interrog. pron.who? which? what?
ergō (adv.)therefore, then; quid ergō? what then?
nōn, adv.not
rēx, rēgis, m.king
quoque, adv.also
occīdō, -cīdere, -cīdī, -cīsuscut down, kill
soleō, -ēre, solitus sumbe accustomed, usually do
sed, conj.but
quotiēns (adv.)how many times; as often as
is, ea, id, dem. pron.this, that; he, she, it, they
fīō, fierī, factus sumbe done or made, become, happen
pūblicus, -a, -umpublic, of the state (rēs pūblica: the state)
ūtilitās, -ātis f.usefulness, advantage
persuādeō, -suādēre, -suāsi, -suāsuspersuade, prevail upon, induce
tyrannus, -ī m.tyrant, despot
saevitia, -ae f.fierceness, cruelty
cor, cordis n.heart
sum, esse, fuī, futūrusbe
autem, conj.moreover; but, however; now
ā, ab (prep. + abl.)away from, from; by (ā only before consonants)
factum, -ī n.deed, act
distō, -ārestand apart, be distant
nōmen, -minis, n.name (that by which one is known)
nam, conj.for
et, conj.and; et ... et, both ... and
magnus, -a, -umlarge, big, great, mighty; loud
iūs, iūris, n.right, justice, law; iūs dīcere, to pronounce judgment; iūs iūrandum, iūris iūrandī, oath
meritō (adv.)deservedly, rightly
que, enclitic conj.and
praeferō, -ferre, -tulī, -lātumput before, prefer (sē praeferre: show oneself superior)
multus, -a, -ummuch, great; plur., many
possum, posse, potuībe able, have power, can
appellō, -pellāre, -pellāvī, -pellātuscall, name
prohibeō, -hibēre, -hibuī, -hibitushold back, prevent, hinder
quī, quae, quod, rel. pron.who, which
fīnis, -is, m.end, boundary; plur., borders, territory, country
faciō, facere, fēcī, factusmake, do; iter facere, see iter
inopia, -ae f.lack, want, scarcity
hostis, -is, m. and f.enemy, foe
dēscendō, -scendere, -scendī, -scēnsusclimb down, descend
licet, -ēre, -uit or -itum est, impers.is lawful or permitted
ex, ē (prep. + abl.)out of, from; of (ē only before consonants)
dictātūra, -ae f.dictatorship
suus, -a, -umhis, her, its, or their own; his, her, its, their
suī, sibi, sē or sēsē, reflexive pron.himself, herself, itself, themselves
toga, -ae f.toga, the Roman citizen's garment of peace
reddō, -dere, -didī, -ditusgive back, return, restore; render
tamen, adv.however, yet, nevertheless
umquam, adv.ever
tam, adv.so
avidē (adv.)eagerly, greedily
hūmānus, -a, -umof man, human
sanguis, sanguinis, m.blood
bibō, bibere, bibīdrink
quam, adv.how? as; than; with superl., as ... as possible
ille, illa, illud, dem. pron.that; he, she, it, they; ille ... hīc, see hīc
septemseven
mīlle, indecl. adj.a thousand; mīlia, -ium, n. plur., thousands;
cīvis, -is, m. and f.citizen, fellow-citizen, subject
Rōmānus, -a, -umRoman
contrucīdō, -āre, -āvī, -ātuscut down, massacre, butcher
iubeō, iubēre, iussī, iussusbid, order, command
cum, conj.when, while, after; since; although
in, prep. with acc. and abl.with acc.: into, onto, against; with abl.: in, on
vīcīnus, -ī m.neighbor
ad, prep. with acc.to, toward; at, near; for
aedēs, -is f.temple (sg.); house (pl.)
sedeō, sedēre, sēdī, sessussit
exaudiō, -īre, -īvī, -ītumhear (from a distance)
conclāmātiō, -ōnis f.a shouting together, acclamation
tot (indecl.)so many
sub, prep. with acc. and abl.under; sub vesperum, towards evening
gladius, -ī, m.sword
gemō, -ere, -uī, -itusgroan; lament
exterreō, -ēre, -uī, -itusfrighten badly, terrify
senātus, -ūs m.senate
hic, haec, hoc, dem. pron.this; ille ... hīc, that ... this, the former ... the latter
agō, agere, ēgī, āctusdrive; do; pass, lead; grātiās agere, see grātia
inquam, inquis, inquit, defective verbI say, you say, he says
pater, patris, m.father
cōnscrībō, -ere, -scrīpsī, -scrīptumenlist, enroll
sēditiōsus, -a, -umrebellious, stirring up trouble
pauculus, -a, -umvery few, just a few
meus, -a, -ummy, mine
iussus, -ūs, m.bidding, command
mentior, -īrī, -ītus sumlie, tell a lie
paucī, -ae, -a, plur. adj.few
videō, vidēre, vīdī, vīsussee; pass., seem
mox, adv.soon
dē, prep, with abl.down from, from, out of; about, concerning, of
quaerō, quaerere, quaesīvī, quaesītusseek; ask, inquire
quōmodo (adv.)how; in what way
īrāscor, īrāscī, īrātusbe angry
utique (adv.)certainly, by all means; yes indeed
sī, conj.if
hostīlis, -eof the enemy, hostile
īdem, eadem, idem, dem. pron.the same; sometimes to be translated likewise, also
corpus, corporis, n.body
abrumpō, -ere, -rūpī, -ruptusbreak off, cut short
trānseō, -īre, -iī, -itusgo across or over, cross
interim (adv.)meanwhile
dīcō, dīcere, dīxī, dictussay, speak; diem dīcere, to appoint or set a day
clēmentia, -ae, f.mercy, kindness
efficiō, -ficere, -fēcī, -fectusmake or work out, accomplish, effect
ut, conj.as; when; that; ita ut, as
inter, prep, with acc.among, between
discrīmen, -crīminis, n.crisis, peril, danger
uterque, utraque, utrumqueeach, either, both
minus, comp. adv.less
arma, -ōrum, n. plur.arms, weapons
vallō, -āre, -āvī, -ātussurround with a rampart; protect, fortify
alter, -era, -erumone or the other (of two); another, second
habeō, -ēre, -uī, -itushave, hold; consider
mūnīmentum, -ī n.defence, barrier
pāx, pācis f.peace
ūtor, ūtī, ūsususe
timor, -ōris, m.fear
odium, -ī, n.hatred
compescō (conp-), -ere, -pescuīhold in check, restrain; quench (thirst)
neque or nec, conj.and not, nor; neque ... neque, neither ... nor; neque enim, for ... not
ipse, ipsa, ipsum, intensive pron.self, himself, herself, itself, themselves; often to be rendered by very
manus, -ūs, f.hand
committō, -mittere, -mīsī, -missussend together; commit, intrust; expose; proelium committere, to join battle
sēcūrus, -a, -umfree from care, untroubled; careless (of: gen.)
aspiciō, -spicere, -spēxī, -spectuslook at or on, behold
contrārius, -a, -umopposite, facing
invīsus, -a, -umhated, hateful (to: dat.)
quia (conj.)because
timeō, -ēre, -uīfear
volō, velle, voluīwish
exsecrābilis, -eaccursed, detestable; deadly
versus, -ūs m.line (of writing), verse
praeceps, -cipitisheadlong
dō, dare, dedī, datusgive
ōdī, ōdisse, used only in tenses of completed action with the force of tenses of incomplete actionhate
dum, conj.while, as; as long as; until
metuō, -ere, metuīfear, be afraid of
ignārus, -a, -umignorant
quantus, -a, -umhow great or much?
rabiēs, -ēī f.madness, fury
orior, -īrī, -tusarise, come forth, spring up; ortā lūce, at dawn
ubi, adv.where; conj., when
suprā, adv. and prep. with acc.above, before
modus, -ī, m.way, manner
crēscō, -ere, crēvī, crētumgrow, rise (in power)
temperātus, -a, -ummild, temperate
enim, conj.for
cohibeō, -ēre, -uī, -itushold back, restrain, keep in check
animus, -ī, m.mind; heart; spirit, courage
assiduus, -a, -umconstant, unremitting
vērō, adv.in truth, indeed; however
ācer, ācris, ācresharp, shrill
extrēmus, -a, -umlast, extreme, furthest
admoveō, -ēre, -mōvī, -mōtusmove up, bring near
audācia, -ae, f.boldness, audacity
iaceō, -ēre, -uīlie, be prostrate
excitō, -citāre, -citāvī, -citātuscall out, arouse
omnis, -eall, every
experior, -īrī, expertus sumtry, test, experience
suādeō, -ēre, suāsī, suāsusadvise, urge
sīc, adv.so, thus
fera, -ae, f.wild animal, beast
līnea, -ae f.line; thread
pinna, -ae f.feather; battlement on a wall
claudō, -ere, clausī, clausumclose, shut; (agmen) bring up the rear
contineō, -tinēre, -tinuī, -tentushold together, keep within, shut up in; bound
tergum, -ī, n.back
eques, equitis m.horseman; (pl.) cavalry
tēlum, -ī, n.missile, spear, weapon
incessō, -ere, -cessīvīattack, assail; (of feelings) seize
temptō, -āre, -āvī, -ātustry, attempt
fuga, -ae, f.flight
per, prep, with ace.through, by means of
fugiō, fugere, fūgī, fugitūrusflee, run away
prōculcō, -āre, -āvī, -ātustrample on
formīdō, -inis f.fear, dread; something to be dreaded
virtūs, -tūtis, f.manliness, courage, bravery
ultimus, -a, -umfarthest, last
necessitās, -ātis f.necessity, compulsion
extundō, -tundere, -tudī, -tūsusbeat out; batter, smash
relinquō, -linquere, -līquī, -lictusleave behind, leave
oportet, -ēre, oportuit (impersonal)it is right, it is necessary
aliquis, -quid, indef. pron.someone, any one, something, anything, some, any
metus, -ūs m.fear, dread
multō, adv.by much or far, much, far
plūs (adv.)more
spēs, speī, f.hope
perīculum, -ī, n.danger, peril, risk
ostentō, -āre, -āvī, -ātusshow, display; show off
aliōquī (adv.)otherwise; in other respects
quiēscō, -ere, quiēvī, quiētusrest, keep quiet
pār, parisequal
incurrō, -ere, -currī, -cursumrun (into), charge, rush at
iuvō, -āre, iūvī, iūtumhelp
aliēnus, -a, -umbelonging to another, out of place
anima, -ae, f.breath, soul, life
abūtor, -ūtī, -ūsus sumuse up; abuse, take advantage of (+ abl.)
Seneca, De Clementia. Latin text: J. W. Basore, Seneca: Moral Essays I (Loeb, 1928), public domain; digital text from the Perseus Digital Library, CC BY-SA. Word analysis: drafted by our own tagger (trained on the hand-checked texts on this site), with every doubtful word checked by hand. English translation and section titles: written for this app, each checked against the Latin by a second reader.